Pin it
Homemade heart-shaped donuts speak louder than words when showing affection. These baked treats hit the sweet spot between soft cake donut and tasty vanilla topping, with a fun shape that's great for Valentine's Day or whenever you want to make someone feel special. My family gobbled up countless test batches until I nailed down this formula for donuts that look as good as they taste.
I surprised the kids with these pink heart donuts for breakfast last Valentine's Day. They couldn't stop smiling, and putting sprinkles on them together became something we all look forward to now. What makes them so good? A light, fluffy batter and a topping that hardens just right.
Essential Ingredients
- All-purpose flour: It's the base for soft donuts. I always use the spoon-and-level way to measure it
- Full-fat milk: This gives you moist, rich donuts. Try to let it sit out until it's not cold
- Good quality vanilla extract: This isn't where you want to save money; it brings that authentic donut shop taste
- Gel food coloring: It adds bright color without making your glaze runny. Pink or red works great for Valentine's
- Sprinkles: Pick colors and shapes that match what you're celebrating
Step-by-Step Baking Guide
- Set Everything Up:
- Turn on oven to 400°F. Coat your heart-shaped donut pan really well. Put a cooling rack nearby. Make sure all ingredients aren't cold.
- Create Your Batter:
- Stir dry stuff until it's all mixed. In another bowl, blend wet ingredients until smooth. Combine them gently - don't mix too much. Your batter should be thick but still able to squeeze through a bag.
- Put Batter in Pan:
- Scoop batter into piping bag. Fill each heart about ¾ full. Tap the pan to get rid of bubbles. Clean up any spills so they don't burn.
- Bake Them:
- Put in hot oven. Wait 8 minutes. Check if they're done with a toothpick. Let them sit in the pan for 5 minutes after baking.
- Fix Up the Glaze:
- Run powdered sugar through a sifter to get rid of clumps. Add milk bit by bit until it's just right. Split it up and add colors if you want. Keep it slightly warm so it goes on smoothly.
Pin it
Smooth Glazing Method
I've figured out that temperature really matters for good glazing. Make sure your donuts are totally cool, but keep your glaze a little warm for the best results. I dunk each donut at an angle, let the extra drip back into the bowl, then flip it over in one quick move.
Prep Ahead Options
These taste best when you eat them the same day you make them, but I've found some ways to save time. You can mix the batter the evening before and keep it in the piping bag in your fridge. Just give it time to warm up before you start baking.
Playing With Colors
To get that sweet Valentine's pink, I start with just a tiny bit of gel color and add more as needed. Sometimes I make a set with three different pinks - light, medium, and dark - which looks super pretty when they're all displayed together.
Setting Up Decoration Stations
Get everything ready with different colored toppings and sprinkle choices. I put parchment paper underneath everything for easy cleanup and use flat, wide bowls for the sprinkles. The kids at our house can't get enough of this part.
Fixing Common Problems
If your donuts won't come out of the pan, try putting the greased pan in the fridge for 10 minutes before adding batter. When your glaze is too stiff, just add a little milk, one teaspoon at a time, until it looks right.
Changing Them Up For Different Events
Pink works great for Valentine's, but I switch colors depending on what we're celebrating - soft colors for Easter, orange and black for Halloween, red and green during Christmas time. You can really do anything!
Pin it
These heart-shaped donuts have grown into something bigger than just a Valentine's treat at our house - they've become our way of baking love into something sweet. Whether you're making them as a surprise or just wanting to brighten someone's day, these donuts always get people smiling. Something almost magical happens when you mix soft cake, sweet glaze and fun decorations - ordinary moments turn into little celebrations.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why use piping for the batter?
- It keeps the batter neat and ensures all donuts look consistent.
- → How do I get that gradient color?
- Work from the lightest pink shade, adding tiny amounts of color as you go for each layer.
- → What if I don't have a donut pan?
- A donut pan is necessary to get that classic shape.
- → How long will these last?
- They taste the best for 2 days if stored in an airtight container at room temperature.
- → Can I freeze the donuts?
- Yes, freeze them without icing for up to 2 months, then glaze them once thawed.