Pin it
This Italian-style flavored butter has totally changed my plain bread into something that feels like it came from a fancy trattoria, and honestly, it’s shockingly simple to whip up at home.
Came up with this during a last-minute dinner, when all I had was some bread and a handful of things lying around. People loved it so much, they insisted on leaving with their own jars!
Essential Ingredients
- Baguette or French loaf: You want bread that's crisp outside with a soft center to hold all that buttery goodness
- 1/4 teaspoon fine sea salt: This blends in smoothly and seasons everything just right
- 1/2 tablespoon minced garlic: Pick fresh, firm cloves and skip any sprouted ones to keep the flavor mellow
- 2 tablespoons fresh basil, chopped: Fresh basil really boosts the taste; dried just can't compare
- 2 tablespoons pepperoni, minced: Go for a nice artisan pepperoni if you can for extra depth
- 1 cup unsalted butter, room temp: Quality here gives you that dreamy, creamy finish
Simple Step-by-Step
- Spread and Enjoy:
- Spoon a thick layer onto warm toasted bread, or melt it right over hot veggies and fresh pasta if you’re feeling fancy.
- Season to Taste:
- Dust your salt in, swirl it until mixed, then taste and tweak if you want a tad more flavor.
- Add the Extras:
- Gently stir in basil, minced pepperoni, and garlic, folding everything in to keep the butter soft and fluffy.
- Whip That Butter:
- Use a metal whisk to beat the butter for about three minutes until it’s really light and airy—room temp butter works best for this part so you don’t get lumps.
Basil’s hands-down my favorite here—you just can’t beat how fresh it keeps things. When my kid was small, she actually called this her “magic green spread” and wanted it on everything, even her morning toast.
Storage & Make-Ahead
To keep this butter, just roll it up in parchment into a log shape and chill it. Slice off as much as you need any time. Want it to last? Wrap it tightly in foil and pop it in a freezer bag, then stick it in the freezer—it’ll taste great for months.
Pin it
Swaps & Variations
For a veggie-friendly twist, swap out pepperoni with finely cut sun-dried tomatoes and a pinch of red pepper flakes. Throw in fresh oregano or thyme with your basil for a greener, bolder sauce. Or stir in shredded parmesan if cheese is your thing and you want it extra rich.
Serving Suggestions
If you’re after a fancy starter, scoop the butter into small balls and roll them through chopped herbs or spices, then chill. Serve on a board with some bread and crackers. For a cozy dinner, let the butter melt over hot pasta right at the table for instant richness.
Fun Food Origins
This kind of flavored butter—what the French call "maître d'hôtel butter"—got an Italian update with Mediterranean faves like basil and pepperoni. It mixes French and Italian food just right, and really brings a classic pizza parlor vibe to your table.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How can I store the Italian butter?
Store it in an airtight container in the fridge for up to a week. For longer storage, freeze it instead.
- → Can pepperoni be swapped out for something else?
Sure, try thin ham slices, sun-dried tomatoes, or even chopped olives for a twist in flavors.
- → What goes best with this butter?
Toast, baked potatoes, or steamed veggies all pair wonderfully with this flavorful butter.
- → Can salted butter be used instead of unsalted?
Yes, but adjust the salt amount to avoid it ending up too salty.
- → How do I make the butter softer for easier spreading?
Use an electric whisk or mixer to give it a light and airy consistency.