Pin it
I'm completely in love with these Coffee Cream Cookies and can't wait for you to try them. Imagine biting into a melt-in-your-mouth soft cookie that captures all the flavors of that classic Italian sweet treat, but in a handy cookie form you can nibble anytime. I've crowned each one with a cloud of whipped mascarpone and a light sprinkle of cocoa. They're such a hit that my folks now demand I bring them to every family get-together.
How These Delightful Cookies Came To Be
Ever had that feeling when you're craving a fancy dessert but don't want the hassle of making something complicated? That's exactly what sparked these cookies. I wanted something with those familiar coffee-cream flavors but needed treats I could tuck into my children's lunch boxes. After many cups of coffee and endless sampling sessions (someone had to do it), these cookies took shape. What's awesome is they need mostly stuff you already have at home plus some mascarpone.
What You'll Need
- Butter: Melt one stick and set it aside to cool while gathering your other stuff.
- Brown Sugar: It's the secret to getting that incredible softness and adds a wonderful warm sweetness I absolutely adore.
- Instant Coffee: Nothing fancy needed here. Whatever jar you've got in your cupboard will work fine.
- Cocoa Powder: Dutch processed works best, but don't worry if you only have regular.
- Mascarpone: This Italian cheese is worth every penny. Make sure it's sitting out before you start.
- Vanilla: Go for pure extract if you can, it really boosts the flavor.
- Egg: You'll just need one, preferably not cold from the fridge.
- The Basics: Don't forget your flour, baking powder, baking soda, and a touch of salt.
Making Cookie Magic Happen
- Get Started
- Start by melting your butter and letting it cool off while gathering everything else. Mix it with sugars until everything looks damp and sandy. Add your egg and a splash of vanilla, then stir it all up well.
- Handle The Dry Stuff
- In a separate bowl, combine your flour and other powder ingredients. I like to give them a quick mix so everything blends together nicely.
- Cool Things Down
- Form your mixture into little balls about ping pong ball size. This next part isn't optional - they must go in the fridge for a while, you'll thank me later.
- Baking Time
- Warm your oven to 180°C. After it's hot, put those cold dough balls in and bake until just barely done. We want them soft and tender, not tough!
The Luscious Topping
- Fluff It Up
- Take that mascarpone (which should be sitting out getting warm) and beat it with vanilla until it gets all light and airy. I usually tackle this job while waiting for cookies to cool because waiting isn't my strong point.
- Finishing Touches
- When cookies are completely cooled down, add a dollop or swirl of that fluffy mascarpone mixture. Finish with a light dusting of cocoa and try to save some for everyone else (nearly impossible).
Insider Tricks
After making these treats countless times, let me share what I've learned along the way. Use a kitchen scale if you have one for consistent results every time. The cooling step isn't something you can skip - trust me on this one. Spend a few extra bucks on quality mascarpone as it really makes these special. And handle the cookie dough gently - no need to manhandle it.
Keeping Them Fresh
You'll need to keep these cookies in your fridge because of that creamy topping. They'll stay tasty for a few days though they rarely last that long at my place. Want to plan ahead? Make balls of dough and stick them in the freezer. Then you can bake a batch whenever you want something sweet. I always keep some frozen dough ready for when cookie cravings strike.
Tasty Variations
I love tweaking this recipe now and then for fun. Recently I switched out the cocoa dust for shaved dark chocolate and wow, what a treat. If you love coffee as much as my hubby does, try putting more espresso powder into the mascarpone. During the holidays? I scatter some smashed candy canes on top and everyone fights over them.
Common Questions
My buddy wanted to know if making larger cookies works and absolutely it does! Just give them a bit more time in the oven. My sis always preps the dough the evening before and swears they come out better. And yes you can definitely freeze your cookie dough - I do this constantly. Just let them sit out a little while before baking.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I prep these cookies ahead?
- You can bake the cookies and prepare the cream in advance. Keep cookies in an airtight container and the cream in the fridge, then assemble just before serving to keep them fresh.
- → What’s a good swap for espresso powder?
- Sub in instant coffee powder, though espresso gives a bolder taste. Grind coffee powder finer for better mixing. If using brewed coffee, adjust other liquids in the recipe.
- → Why is chilling the dough necessary?
- It stops the cookies from spreading too much during baking and enhances the flavor. Butter firms up while chilling, ensuring the dough holds better.
- → Where should I store these cookies?
- After adding cream, keep them in the fridge and enjoy within 2 days. Plain cookies last up to 5 days in a sealed container at room temperature.
- → Are these cookies freezer-friendly?
- You can freeze the cookies without cream for up to 3 months. Let them thaw fully before adding the topping. The cream should always be fresh for best results.