Pin it
For years now, I've been whipping up these cloud-soft Italian Christmas Cookies that always get people grinning. They've got this gentle almond taste, sweet topping and fun colorful sprinkles that really catch the holiday baking spirit. Though they shine at Christmas, these little joy bites are honestly too tasty to only make once a year. Whenever I need something extra special, these are my go-to treats.
Why These Treats Stand Out
These cookies feel like mini celebrations in every bite. They've got an incredibly pillowy texture, almost cake-like, with just enough almond or vanilla flavor coming through. The sweet coating on top works perfectly with those crunchy, colorful sprinkles. What I really love is how flexible they are—just switch up the flavors and decorations and they'll fit any event or party.
Round Up Your Supplies
- All-Purpose Flour: Don't scoop from the bag—use the spoon and level method for that dreamy cake-like softness.
- Baking Powder: This creates that wonderful bounce and airy feel in our cookies.
- Butter: Room temperature salted butter works best for me. Going with unsalted? Just toss in a small dash of salt.
- Eggs: Go for large ones to get that perfect soft crumb texture.
- Extracts: Pick your favorite—maybe almond, vanilla, or try anise for a true Italian touch.
- Powdered Sugar: This makes the creamiest, silkiest topping possible.
- Sprinkles: The tiny nonpareils are traditional, but any festive decoration will do the trick.
Baking Time Begins
- Put Together Your Dough
- Begin by mixing your baking powder with flour and put it aside. Beat your butter until it's light, then add eggs, sugar and whatever extract you chose. Fold in your dry mix gently. Let the dough cool in your fridge for at least 60 minutes.
- Form and Bake Your Cookies
- Roll the dough into small balls using a cookie scoop or tablespoon. Put them on parchment-covered baking sheets about an inch apart. Bake at 350°F for around 8-10 minutes until they're done and just starting to turn golden on the bottom.
- Whip Up The Topping
- As they cool down, mix your topping with powdered sugar, extract and just a bit of milk until it's the right thickness. Dunk each cool cookie, let extra drip away, then quickly add sprinkles before the coating hardens.
My Top Cookie Tricks
Want the softest cookies ever? Don't mix your dough too much—just until everything comes together. Don't skip that cooling time in the fridge or they'll spread too much. Make sure your cookies are totally cool before adding the topping, otherwise it'll just slide off. If your dough gets sticky, try a bit of cooking spray on your hands.
Shake Things Up
These cookies can transform for any event. Try them with lemon extract when spring comes or use anise for that old-school Italian feel. Change those sprinkles to crushed candy canes during Christmas or light pastels for Easter. They're really just waiting for whatever creative touch you want to add.
Store Them Right
These yummy treats stay soft for about a week if you keep them in an airtight container at room temp. Need to make them ahead? Freeze them without topping in a sealed container for up to 3 months. Just thaw them out and add fresh topping and sprinkles when you're ready to enjoy them.
Tasty Combinations
These cookies taste amazing with a big cup of hot chocolate when it's cold outside. They're great with coffee or tea too. When I have guests over, I like to put them on a plate with chocolate mint cookies and spicy gingerbread cookies for a really festive mix.
Get The Kids Involved
Kids love making these cookies. My little ones can't wait to decorate them with different sprinkles and watch the topping harden. It's become our special holiday thing to do together, and those memories mean even more than how good the cookies taste.
A Timeless Sweet Treat
These Italian Christmas Cookies go beyond just being dessert. They're small bites of family custom that bring warmth to every holiday get-together. Their subtle sweetness and festive look make them hard for anyone to turn down. In my family, they've grown into a symbol of holiday love that we pass down through the years.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I swap almond extract for other flavors?
- Absolutely! You can go with vanilla or anise extract depending on your taste. Each one gives the cookies a unique twist.
- → What’s the point of chilling the dough?
- It makes the dough less sticky and easier to roll. Plus, it keeps the cookies from spreading too much in the oven.
- → How do I tell if the cookies are ready?
- They should stay pale but feel set after 8-10 minutes. Don’t let them brown—they’ll firm up more as they cool.
- → Can I freeze them before decorating?
- Yep, freeze them without frosting. When ready, let them thaw completely, then add glaze and sprinkles.
- → How do I store these cookies?
- Use an airtight container at room temperature. Add wax paper between layers to keep the icing and sprinkles neat.