Pin it
I discovered Sticky Toffee Pudding during a downpour in London and it's been my kitchen staple ever since. There's something wonderful when that hot toffee sauce gets soaked up by the soft, date-studded cake. My whole house smells amazingly like caramel while it's cooking. It's now my favorite treat when I want to impress someone special.
The Wonder of This Beloved Dessert
Everyone who tries this at my gatherings wants to know how to make it. The moist sponge gets its amazing texture from dates, and pouring that warm sauce over it turns everything into total comfort food. My little girl now wants this instead of regular birthday cake. When vanilla ice cream melts on the hot pudding, it makes an absolutely dreamy treat.
Three Key Components
- The base layer: Our date-filled sponge comes out incredibly soft and juicy every single time. Those dates practically disappear into the mix leaving tiny sweet caramel spots.
- The top layer: The sauce I make creates this shiny, beautiful coating that soaks into each mouthful.
- The perfect sides: A bit of freshly whipped cream or some vanilla ice cream makes this dessert incredible. I sometimes toss some crushed nuts on top for a bit of crunch.
Pick Quality Dates
Through many attempts at making this pudding, I've found that spending extra on proper Medjool dates really matters. They're sweeter and fuller which creates that amazing cake texture. I occasionally throw in some dried figs for something different. Just make sure you soak them properly in hot water until they're completely soft and ready to blend into your mixture.
Creating Your Dessert
- Getting Started
- I begin by cutting up my dates and giving them a hot soak with baking soda. This 15-minute bath is why my cake turns out so incredibly moist.
- Preparing Your Ingredients
- During the date soaking time, I mix my dry stuff together. Just simple flour, baking powder and a touch of salt.
- Working With Butter
- Then comes the fun part, beating butter and brown sugar until it looks fluffy. After that, I add eggs and vanilla.
- Mixing Everything
- When those dates finish soaking, I carefully combine all ingredients. The mixture looks smooth as silk now.
- Baking Time
- I pour everything into my trusty baking dish and cook at 350°F. You won't believe how good your kitchen will smell.
- Making The Sauce
- While it cooks, I whip up that amazing toffee sauce. Just mix butter, brown sugar and cream until it looks like liquid gold.
- Finishing Touches
- After cooling briefly, I cover everything with warm sauce. It's absolutely delicious.
Storing Your Dessert
I always remind everyone this dessert tastes best when it's warm. Any leftover portions can go in your fridge for up to 4 days. Just remember to warm each piece gently before you eat it. I keep some toffee sauce separate in the fridge and warm it up to pour over each serving. Add a fresh scoop of ice cream on top and it's just as good as when you first made it.
Mistakes To Avoid
- Never rush the date soaking: I found out the hard way that dates need this relaxing time to create the right consistency.
- Don't overmix: I combine everything just enough to blend it. Mixing too much will make your pudding tough.
- Check it early: I start looking at mine after 25 minutes. You'll want a clean toothpick but the middle should still feel soft.
- Serve it hot: This treat was created to enjoy while warm. It just isn't as tasty when it's cold.
Smart Suggestions
- Buy the best: Those juicy Medjool dates might be pricier but they truly enhance the final flavor.
- Try new tastes: I sometimes add a bit of ginger or nutmeg to my batter. My man loves when I pour a little bourbon into the sauce.
- Prep beforehand: For dinner parties, I often bake this a day early. It warms up wonderfully.
- Crockpot version: On hectic days, I use my slow cooker. The pudding turns out super moist after cooking about 3 hours on low.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What does baking soda do to the dates?
It softens the dates and boosts the caramel flavor in the pudding. You’ll also notice the sponge comes out much softer with this method.
- → Can I prep this in advance?
Sure can! Bake the pudding ahead of time and reheat it when needed. The sauce works the same—store it and warm it up before serving.
- → How do I store leftovers?
Keep any leftover pudding at room temperature for 2 days or refrigerated for up to 5 days. Put the sauce in the fridge and gently reheat it as needed.
- → What goes well with it?
Vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, or extra toffee sauce are all great choices. Cold ice cream with warm pudding is especially delicious!
- → Why should butter be soft?
Soft butter mixes smoothly with sugar, making the sponge lighter and fluffier. This step ensures the right texture for your pudding.