Pin it
I've baked these butter pecan cookies so many times and they're always a hit. When they're in the oven, the smell of toasted nuts fills the air and honestly, it just takes me back to baking with my mom on chilly afternoons. You get that rich buttery taste with a good crunch from the pecans in every bite. Pair them with coffee or toss one in a lunchbox—you can't go wrong.
Why You'll Love These Cookies
It's all about that rich buttery pecan taste and how these cookies pretty much melt on your tongue. They're super handy to have around—dress them up for parties or toss them in a lunch bag. When life gets hectic, I make extra and freeze them. That way, I'm never caught off guard if someone pops in for a surprise visit.
What You Need
- Self rising flour, 2 1/2 cups: This one keeps the cookies light as air and a bit fluffy.
- Pure vanilla extract, 2 teaspoons: Real vanilla is worth it and you’ll taste the difference every time.
- Soft butter, 1 cup: Let it hang out on the counter so it’s easy to blend. The better the butter, the tastier the cookie.
- Brown sugar, 1 cup: You’ll love the deep caramel flavor and soft texture it brings.
- Pecans, 2 cups: Chop most for mixing in—save a handful of halves for topping. Sneaking a few while baking? Hard to resist.
- Eggs, 2 large: Room temp eggs mix better, so get them out early with your butter.
Time to Bake Deliciousness
- Roll and Bake
- Crank the oven up to 375°F. Scoop out little bits of dough, roll them, press into the toasted pecans, and crown each with a pecan half. Bake about 11 minutes till they look golden and happy.
- Chill the Dough
- Once everything's mixed, let the dough rest in the fridge for an hour—it’ll be easier to shape later.
- Pecan Toasting Magic
- Heat your oven to 325°F first. Mix up those chopped pecans with a dab of butter and toast for about 6 minutes—once your kitchen smells amazing, they’re good. Let them cool so they’re easy to handle.
Easy Twists to Try
Sometimes I toss in other nuts when I want something different. Try a squirt of honey before they bake for a fun hint of sweetness. If hazelnuts are your thing, swap those in with hazelnut flavoring for a coffee shop vibe at home—my sister asks for that version every time.
Best Ways to Store Them
Keep these cookies fresh on your countertop in a sealed container or stash them in the fridge. For big batches, pop them in freezer bags—they'll keep for months. Need a sweet pick-me-up? Just grab one straight from the freezer.
Tips From My Kitchen
A bit of butter pecan extract takes the flavor to the next level. They're a showstopper next to anything chocolate during the holidays. Baking for vegan friends? Use plant-based butter and egg replacements—they still come out awesome.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why should pecans be toasted earlier?
It brings out deeper nutty flavors and gives them a crunch. Toasting them in butter keeps them rich without burning.
- → What does chilling the dough do?
It firms up buttery dough, making it less sticky to work with and keeping cookies the perfect shape while baking.
- → Why coat pecans with egg whites?
The egg white binds the pecans to cookies and gives them a bit of shine after baking. Think of it as edible glue!
- → Is all-purpose flour okay instead of self-rising?
Swap each cup of self-rising with all-purpose flour added with 1½ teaspoons baking powder and ¼ teaspoon salt.
- → Can these cookies be frozen?
Yes! They freeze beautifully for up to 3 months. Use parchment paper between layers in an airtight box.