Pin it
There's nothing fancy here, but this mushroom pasta brings together the deep woodland taste of mushrooms and punchy garlic, all coated in a smooth, buttery mix. A squeeze of fresh lemon cuts through the richness, while grated Parmesan adds that mouthwatering umami kick that'll make you want seconds.
I've thrown this together so many times, both when I'm in a rush on weeknights and when friends come over. It's one of those dishes that's super easy but still makes people think you're a kitchen wizard. Just don't rush those mushrooms - letting them get that gorgeous golden color makes all the difference.
Key Components and Shopping Advice
- Cremini Mushrooms: Go for ones that feel solid and look about the same size with dry, clean caps. Skip any that feel wet or show dark marks.
- Pappardelle: The broad shape of these noodles grabs onto sauce beautifully. Try to find ones made with eggs for a richer taste.
- Parmesan Cheese: Get it in chunk form and grate it yourself - the bagged stuff won't melt into your sauce properly.
- Fresh Parsley: Pick out bunches with vibrant green, perky leaves. Don't toss the stems - they pack extra flavor.
- Dijon Mustard: Grab the real French stuff for that zingy flavor that makes mushrooms taste even better.
Step-by-Step Cooking Guide
- Step 1: Getting Your Pasta Just Right
- Make your water as salty as ocean water. Once you drop the pasta in, give it a good stir right away so it doesn't clump together. Keep testing it - you want it a tiny bit firm when you bite. Don't pour all the water out - scoop some out first to help make your sauce smooth.
- Step 2: Cooking Mushrooms to Perfection
- Give those mushrooms plenty of space in the pan. Don't keep pushing them around too much. They'll get wet first as they release juices, then wait for that moisture to dry up. You'll know they're ready when the edges turn a nice golden brown.
- Step 3: Putting Together Your Sauce
- Cook the garlic just until you can smell it - too long and it gets bitter. Add the Dijon bit by bit while stirring. Let everything bubble gently to thicken slightly. Splash in pasta water a little at a time while mixing until it's just how you want it.
Pin it
I come from an Italian family where we always believed simple pasta needs top-notch ingredients. My mom would always say when you're using fewer items in a dish, each one matters more. The mushrooms especially need to be super fresh - they're the real stars here.
What makes this dish so good is how uncomplicated it is. Every time I cook it, I can't get over how just a handful of basic ingredients can turn into something that tastes so fancy.
Pin it
This pasta has become what I make whenever I need something cozy and satisfying. Whether I'm eating alone or feeding a bunch of friends, it always hits the spot with its simple but rich flavors.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which mushrooms should I use?
- Cremini is a great pick, but white button or portobello work just as well.
- → Can I switch pasta shapes?
- Absolutely! Go for penne, rotini, or bowties if you’d like.
- → What’s the point of mustard?
- It gives the dish a nice punch of flavor and a little tangy twist.
- → Is this good for meal prep?
- It's better right after cooking since the pasta can soak up the sauce in the fridge.
- → How do I make it richer?
- Stir in some heavy cream with the broth for a luxuriously creamy finish.