Pin it
This dreamy Eggnog Cheesecake brings together all the wonderful magic of holiday treats. I've changed up the classic cheesecake by blending the smooth, spiced taste of eggnog with a crumbly gingersnap base and fluffy whipped cream on top. It's that wow-factor dessert your holiday spread can't go without - plus you can make it a day early so you can spend more time hanging out with family and friends.
Why This Delightful Creation Stands Out
Everyone will gasp when you set this stunner on the table. The velvety filling tastes exactly like holiday eggnog while the zingy gingersnap crust gives you that satisfying crunch. I'm so happy I can whip this up a day ahead, giving me extra hours to join in the fun. And don't forget the best part - that soft crown of whipped cream and glittering sugared cranberries that makes it look absolutely gorgeous.
What You'll Want to Gather
- Eggnog: The stuff from the store works great but if you're feeling fancy, homemade takes it up another level.
- Cream Cheese: Go for the full-fat blocks instead of tubs - they'll give you that perfect smooth texture you're after.
- Gingersnap Cookies: I grab English gingersnaps for their bold spicy kick, but you might need to tweak the sugar depending on how sweet your cookies are.
- Heavy Cream: You'll need this for that soft, billowy topping you won't want to miss.
- Nutmeg: Try to get whole nutmeg and grate it yourself - the smell is simply amazing.
- Rum: Just a tiny bit in the whipped cream turns this from yummy to absolutely incredible.
Cooking Steps Made Simple
- Get Your Crust Ready
- Smash up those gingersnaps, mix them with melted butter and a tiny bit of salt, push into your springform pan and pop in the oven till you catch that wonderful ginger smell, around 8 to 10 minutes.
- Mix Your Filling
- Whip your softened cream cheese with sugar and vanilla until it's nice and smooth. Drop in eggs one by one, then pour in that rich eggnog and some freshly grated nutmeg. Mix just enough - we don't want bubbles trapped inside.
- Prepare Your Water Trick
- This step makes all the difference. Put your cheesecake pan inside a bigger one and fill with hot water halfway up the sides.
- Cook It Slowly
- Let it bake about 70 to 80 minutes, then switch off the heat, crack the oven door, and let it cool gradually. After that, it needs at least 8 hours chilling in the fridge.
- Put on the Pretty Stuff
- Beat some cream with sugar, vanilla, and that little splash of rum. Spread over the top and fix up those beautiful sugared cranberries and fresh rosemary sprigs.
Insider Tricks for Perfect Results
Wondering how I get that super smooth texture every time? It all starts with ingredients that aren't cold, especially the cream cheese. When you add the eggs, don't mix too hard - too many bubbles can cause cracks. That water bath might seem like extra work but trust me, it's totally worth it. No big enough pan? Just wrap your springform really well in foil and you're all set.
Timing Tips and Storage Ideas
What's great about this cheesecake? You can fix it ahead of time. It actually needs that overnight stay in the fridge to reach its best texture. You can keep it covered in the fridge up to 4 days, though at my place it's always gone way before then. Want to plan way ahead? Stick the whole thing or cut slices in the freezer for up to 2 months. Just let it thaw in the fridge overnight and save the pretty decorating for when you're ready to serve.
Getting That Water Bath Just Right
Let's chat about how to get that smooth, crack-free top. My go-to trick is putting the springform in a slightly bigger pan before adding hot water. Worried water might leak in? Try using a sous vide bag instead of foil. If you're using a regular cake pan, just put parchment paper on the bottom - it makes getting the cake out so much easier.
Adding Those Gorgeous Final Touches
The last bits of decoration really make this cheesecake stand out. The rum-flavored whipped cream goes so well with sugared cranberries and little bits of fresh rosemary, creating a lovely winter wonderland look. A light sprinkle of fresh nutmeg adds that last festive touch. For clean, pretty slices, run your knife under hot water and wipe it between cuts. Serve with coffee or my favorite, a warm mug of holiday mulled wine.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How long in advance can I prepare this cake?
- This cake can be prepped 2 days in advance. Cover and chill it in the fridge, adding the final toppings right before you serve.
- → What's the purpose of a water bath?
- A water bath keeps the heat even, which stops cracks and ensures a nice texture. Be sure to wrap the pan so water doesn't get inside.
- → Is this cake okay to freeze?
- Definitely! Freeze it for up to 2 months in a sealed container. Let it thaw overnight in the fridge before serving.
- → What kind of cream cheese works best?
- Use full-fat brick cream cheese for a sturdy and rich texture. Avoid spreadable or low-fat versions.
- → Can I make this cake without rum?
- Yep, skip the rum in the whipped topping. The eggnog flavor stays fully intact without alcohol unless it's already in your eggnog.