Pin it
This old-school pumpkin treat comes out with a crisp, crackly crust and super silky filling every time. You follow easy steps and real measurements, so you'll skip annoying things like splits in the top or a soggy base. It’s awesome for any get-together or a holiday. Each slice brings together pure pumpkin, sweet and cozy spices, and creamy custard in a way that just works—no stress needed.
Why You'll Love This Proven Method
Forget about weird pie problems. This one sorts them out with simple temperature tricks and spot-on measurements. Starting with a pre-cooked crust means things stay crunchy, and the filling sets smoothly with zero cracks. Using Libby's pumpkin puree and the right spices gives you the same happy result every time. The steps are built so nobody stumbles, no matter how new you are to making pie from scratch.
Must-Have Ingredients
- Evaporated Milk: Grab 1¼ cups, room temp works best.
- Sugars: ½ cup standard sugar and the same amount of packed light brown sugar.
- Pumpkin Puree: 15 oz can (about 1¾ cups), plain pumpkin, Libby's preferred, not pie mix.
- Pie Crust: 9-inch deep-dish shell (you can use homemade or a frozen one), super cold before you start.
- Spices: 1 teaspoon each of ginger and cinnamon, ½ teaspoon nutmeg, and ⅛ teaspoon each black pepper and cloves.
- Salt: ½ teaspoon regular fine table salt.
- Flour: 2 flat tablespoons all-purpose flour.
- Eggs: 1 big whole egg plus 3 yolks, all at room temp.
Pin it
Simple Pumpkin Pie Steps
- Cooling Down and Slicing
- Park the baked pie on a rack for three hours. Set it on the counter at room temp. Chill it in the fridge at least four hours before you plan to cut a piece.
- Pour and Finish Bake
- Fill up your hot crust with the pumpkin stuff. Let it bake in a 325°F oven for 50 to 60 minutes. When you wiggle the pan, the middle should jiggle a bit. It’s good to go when the inside temp is 175°F.
- Mix Up the Pumpkin Filling
- Toss pumpkin, eggs, sugars, flour, salt, the spice mix, and milk into a big bowl. Whisk it together—keep going ’til the whole mix is silky and there’s nothing lumpy.
- Crust First Steps
- Press your crust into a deep 9-inch pie plate. Pop it in the fridge for half an hour at 40°F. Start heating the oven on the center rack to 375°F.
- Pre-Bake for Crunch
- Cover your chilly crust with some parchment paper. Fill it up with pie weights. Bake for 20 minutes, just until the edges are set. Take out the weights and paper, use foil to wrap the rim, and bake for another 15 or 20 minutes until it’s lightly golden. Drop the oven temp to 325°F.
Typical Mishaps and Fixes
Pumpkin pie goes sideways for a few big reasons: the way the crust bakes, how the filling sets, or oven temp issues. The type of pie pan makes a difference—ceramic needs more time than metal. Don’t just go by time; keep an eye out. You want the filling to have a gentle wobble, not slosh, and the rim shouldn’t get too dark. Turning down the heat helps keep cracks away. That first bake for the crust stops the dreaded soggy bottom.
How Each Ingredient Works
Every part has a job here. Pumpkin keeps the whole slice holding together. Evaporated milk makes it creamy but not runny. Whole egg and extra yolks bring a nice, soft custard feel. Brown sugar gives it deep, caramel notes and white sugar keeps it sweet enough. The hit of different spices warms up every bite, and black pepper quietly brings a bit of zing—classic pumpkin pie flavor at its best.
Pre-Baking Know-How
Crust going soggy? Pre-baking is your shield. Chilling the dough stops shrinkage. Pile on pie weights so the shape holds up. Do a quick bake with the weights, then another without them, so things brown up evenly. Look for just-light color, not burnt edges, so you don’t end up with an overdone crust.
How to Nail the Filling
To get the filling set just right, pay close attention to temps and how you mix. Let eggs and milk hit room temp for smoother blending. Whisk away—don’t stop until it’s totally smooth and there aren’t any eggy streaks. For a super smooth mix, run it through a fine sieve. Pour in the filling while that crust is still warm so baking starts right away. Make sure the filling doesn’t go all the way up to the edge. Leave space so it won’t overflow.
Pin it
How to Store or Prep Ahead
Keep your baked pie in the fridge, loosely covered with foil, and it’ll be good for four days. Wrapped tight first in plastic, then foil, a cooled pie can hit the freezer for a month. Thaw it overnight in the fridge. Let it sit on the counter for an hour before serving. Don’t try to freeze raw filling or uncooked crust. If you want to prep ahead, you can bake and freeze just the crust edge two weeks before adding filling and baking the whole thing.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → No evaporated milk, what should I use?
Heavy cream gives great flavor. For a lighter option, combine half cream with half whole milk. Coconut milk works but adds a twist to the taste. Warm it beforehand and use the same quantity the recipe mentions. Sweetened condensed milk can work too; just use less sugar if you go that route.
- → Can I make this ahead of time?
Absolutely! This dish is great prepped in advance. Cook it a day early and refrigerate. Bring it out 30 minutes before serving. Crust can be made two days ahead, then filled and baked the next day. It'll last up to 4 days in the fridge, just keep it wrapped to stop drying out.
- → How can I keep my crust from going soggy?
Pre-bake the crust first! Cover it with parchment, fill it with weights or beans, and bake for 15 minutes covered, then 10 minutes uncovered. Brush the hot crust with egg white and let it cool fully before filling. Some people sprinkle crushed cookies at the bottom as a little extra barrier.
- → How long will it last?
Store in the fridge for up to 4 days if wrapped well. Watch for a watery texture or odd smells as spoilage signs. Sometimes, slices last better than the whole pie. Let it warm to room temperature before eating. Whipped cream on top is best used within 1-2 days.
- → Can I freeze it?
It freezes well for a month if tightly wrapped. Freezing as a whole pie works best. Defrost overnight in the fridge. While texture might shift slightly, the taste stays great. You can freeze just the filling and make a fresh crust later too. Avoid freezing whipped cream along with it.
Conclusion
Fan of pumpkin? Whip up a loaf of pumpkin bread for breakfast. Bake a creamy pumpkin cheesecake. Or enjoy pumpkin muffins bursting with cozy spices!