Creamy Cheesy Broccoli

Craving a big spoonful of cheesy comfort? This broccoli cheddar soup is ready in just half an hour. It's creamy, thick, and packed with fresh broccoli. Makes you think of Panera, but it’s all homemade.

Reasons You'll Love This

Cold weather calls for something cozy and this one really hits the spot. It's bursting with broccoli and gooey cheese. Kids dig it, adults too. Got cheese, milk, and broccoli on hand? Then you’re all set. Awesome for weeknights and nice enough to serve guests.

Everything You'll Grab

• Cheese: 2 cups sharp cheddar, shred yourself for best melt
• Butter: 4 tablespoons, real deal (not margarine)
• Broccoli: 4 cups fresh, break into small florets
• Carrot: 1 big one, julienned or cut thin
• Salt: 1 hefty tablespoon, any type works here
• Black Pepper: Fresh ground brings loads of flavor
• Garlic: 4 fresh cloves, minced
• Milk: 2 cups whole is creamiest
• Onion: 1 large yellow, dice it up
• Broth: 2 cups, veggie or chicken—your pick
• Mustard: 1 tablespoon Dijon for some tang
• Flour: 1/4 cup all-purpose
• Salt/Pepper: Tweak after cooking to your liking

Pin it

Simple Way to Make It

Dishing it up:

Scoop into bowls while it's super hot. Sprinkle extra cheese on top if you want more. As it sits, it’ll get even thicker.

Dial in the taste:

Take a taste. If you think it needs more salt or pepper, add a little at a time. Too thick? Mix in a bit of hot broth until it’s just right.

Melt the cheese:

Now drop the heat down low. Chuck in cheddar a bit at a time. Melt each batch before adding more. Slow and steady so it stays smooth, not stringy.

Double check the veggies:

Stick a fork in some broccoli. If it slides in easy, you're good. Still tough? Let it cook five minutes more.

Cook up the veggies:

Toss in broccoli and carrots. Add Dijon. Simmer on low, gently bubbling for fifteen minutes. Stir every so often so it doesn’t scorch.

Get those liquids in:

Gradually pour in milk while stirring all the time. Stir out lumps. Then add broth, same slow trick. Keep at it till you see bubbles.

Thicken the base:

Garlic goes in next, cook one minute. Dump in flour. Keep stirring non-stop two minutes. It'll look a little paste-like, which is perfect.

Build your base:

Heat up butter in your biggest pot on medium. Toss in onion. Hit it with salt and pepper. Let it soften now for five minutes until see-through.

Prep stuff first:

Chop broccoli to bite size. Shred cheese yourself—prebagged just doesn’t melt well. Dice onion tiny. Smash and cut garlic. Slice carrots real thin.

Ultra Creamy Magic

Always grate your own cheese. The packaged stuff has stuff that makes your soup weird and gritty. Add cheese when it’s barely warm or you’ll get a clumpy mess. For extra smoothness, just keep stirring in the same direction. Swap in whole milk for max creaminess. If your soup gets crazy thick, splash in some hot milk. Skip cold milk since it makes cheese stick together.

Get the Good Stuff

Pick broccoli that looks bright and green—skip any with yellow bits. Small pieces cook up easier. Sharp cheddar brings the strongest cheesy bite. Hunt down orange carrots—lighter colored ones usually taste bland. Fresh garlic is the way to go. If you spot green inside your onions, slice those parts out because they taste off.

Fixing Common Oopsies

Too runny? Whisk a spoon of flour into cold milk and stir it in. On the thicker side? Warm broth does the trick, add a little bit at a time. Cheese not smooth? Turn your heat down and keep stirring. Broccoli not soft? Break it smaller next time. Burned bottom? Drop the heat and mix often. Tastes flat? A small dash of salt does more than adding cheese.

Leftover Tricks

Cool your soup at least an hour before chilling. It'll last up to four days in the fridge. Soup thickens as it sits—totally normal. Reheat on the stove, gently—skip the microwave for best texture. Stir as it warms and add hot milk if you want it thinner. Don’t let it boil hard or cheese separates. Freezing? It gets gritty, so best to finish it fresh.

Pin it

Switch Things Up

Craving heat? Sprinkle in some cayenne. Want extra veggies? Cauliflower fits right in. Need a gluten-free meal? Swap in cornstarch instead of flour. Feeding picky eaters? Toss in more cheese. Feeling fancy? Garnish with bacon bits and a handful of green onion. Need a shortcut? Grab precut broccoli at the store.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use frozen broccoli?

Yup, absolutely! Use around 4 cups, just like fresh. No defrosting needed – toss it in frozen! Small florets cook quicker than the big ones, so if there’s large chunks, break them up first. Check after 5 minutes; it cooks pretty fast. The microwave steam-bag ones work halfway cooked too. Fresh gives the best texture, but frozen’s perfect for lazy days or off-season!

→ What pairs well with this?

You have to try dipping crusty bread – classic! In a hurry? Quick garlic toast is easy: spread butter, sprinkle garlic powder, and broil till golden. Want extra cheesiness? Cheese toast all day! Even crunchy croutons or simple crackers work. Need fresh? A green salad with vinegar dressing balances the richness. Feeling hearty? Pour the soup over a baked potato – so good!

→ How can I skip the wheat?

Use cornstarch instead – mix 3 tablespoons with cold water before adding it. Rice flour works too; sub exactly the same amount. You could try potato starch – excellent for this. Stir in a bit longer than regular flour to lose that raw taste. A gluten-free mix like Bob’s Red Mill does fine too. Make sure you keep stirring while it thickens up, even if it starts runny!

→ What’s the best way to store it?

Cool it down first, then pop it into a container with a tight lid. It’s good in the fridge for about three days. When reheating, heat it low and stir often – that keeps it smooth. A splash of milk helps if it thickened too much. Microwave is fine; use medium power and stir every minute. Freezing is okay, but the texture does change a bit.

→ How do I make it taste even better?

Give these ideas a try: A tiny pinch of nutmeg boosts it surprisingly! A splash of hot sauce or a tiny bit of cayenne gives it a kick. Smoked paprika adds a smoky depth. Use extra sharp cheddar – more flavor! What about a spoon of Dijon mustard or fresh garlic? Even a dash of white wine while sautéing onions takes it to the next level. Just keep it simple!

Conclusion

If you’re into this soup, you’d probably love a cheesy broccoli rice side. Or switch things up with a broccoli-stuffed omelet. Same flavors, different bites!