Pin it
The first time I put together Trisha Yearwood's crockpot mac and cheese, I was hooked. That gooey cheese oozing over every bite of pasta just blew me away. After I found this way to make it, I couldn't even glance at boxed versions again. It's now my top comfort pick for parties, family nights, or whenever we want something warm, melty, and delicious.
Irresistible Comfort Mac and Cheese
Honestly, letting the slow cooker handle everything is my favorite part. While it's bubbling away, I can go get other stuff done. The noodles get wrapped in this rich creamy sauce, almost like a soft blanket. I have fun trying out different cheese blends and add-ons, but the classic always feels extra special to me.
What You’ll Gather
- Paprika: Dust a little on top for a pop of color.
- Salt and pepper: Adjust to however you like it.
- 4 cups sharp cheddar: Shred it yourself—it really does melt better.
- 1 stick butter: Don’t skip the real stuff, it’s worth it.
- 2 cups whole milk: Helps everything turn smooth and dreamy.
- 2 cans evaporated milk: Makes for the thickest, silkiest sauce.
- 1 pound elbow macaroni: Scoops up all the cheesy goodness.
- Cooking spray: A quick spritz keeps cleanup a breeze.
How to Make It
- Finish and Dig In
- Give it all one last stir, scoop it up, and serve while it’s super melty and warm.
- All Set to Cook
- Drop in your noodles, evaporated milk, butter, regular milk, salt, plus almost all the cheese. Mix gently and sprinkle what’s left of the cheese over top.
- Ready Your Slow Cooker
- Lightly coat the inside with cooking spray so nothing gets stuck and cleanup's simple.
- Hands Off While It Cooks
- Pop on the lid then let it go on low heat for three hours or a little more—but don’t peek! You want to keep all that cozy steam inside.
My Favorite Tricks
I’ve honestly made this so many times that I’ve picked up some handy hints. If you grate your own cheese, it turns out way smoother than using pre-grated bags. Don’t over-mix or your pasta will get soggy. I like to check the noodles at about the two-hour point to make sure they’re not overcooked. Hold off on opening the lid while it’s cooking—the trapped steam is essential for that perfect texture.
Mix It Up Your Way
I love switching things around by throwing in velveeta or smoked gouda sometimes. My kids can’t get enough when I finish it with a crunchy breadcrumb topping. If we’re craving extra heat, I’ll toss in jalapeño slices or splash in some hot sauce. On extra cozy days, I swap milk for heavy cream and it gets ultra rich.
Tasty Sides to Try
For us, this mac matches up with just about everything. We serve it with garlic bread, maybe a fresh salad, or next to BBQ chicken and pulled pork. Other nights, it’s the main event with a simple veggie on the plate. No one ever leaves a bite behind because it’s just that good.
People Often Wonder
Folks tell me their pasta gets too soft—it’s usually from cooking it too long or stirring it too much. Gritty sauce is pretty common if you use bagged cheese or turn the heat up too high. Use any pasta shape, but check it so it won’t go mushy. And you don’t need to boil the noodles ahead—the slow cooker takes care of that for you.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why grate your own cheese?
Bagged shredded cheese has a coating that stops it from melting well. Freshly grated melts evenly for a creamier finish.
- → What's the reason for using yolks?
Yolks don’t curdle like whole eggs and give a rich, velvety texture. They’re optional but great if you want extra creaminess.
- → How can I tell it’s ready?
After two hours, check the pasta and stir. Cooking times depend on your slow cooker—pasta should be soft, not mushy. Extend by 30-minute blocks if needed.
- → Can I make a double batch?
Sure! Use a bigger slow cooker and keep an eye on the cooking time. The first time, you might need adjustments but it's doable.
- → Why mix two kinds of milk?
Evaporated milk keeps it rich and stops curdling, while whole milk adds the creamy texture. Together, they make the sauce perfect.