Pin it
You won't have to worry about tricky prep with this turkey—you can forget about brining and basting. Whether it's your first time or you’re a kitchen pro, you’ll get a juicy bird with golden skin every time. Getting the temperature right and slathering on that easy herb butter is the secret for any 12-18 pound turkey.
Why You'll Love It
No stress here—just focus on what counts. Herb butter keeps everything juicy so you can skip all that basting. The usual guesswork is swapped for simple temperature instructions. All you need is a roasting rack, a meat thermometer, and a good knife. Whether you’re feeding a crowd or a few, these no-nonsense directions always come through.
Grab These Ingredients
- Turkey: Get a 12-18 pound bird, make sure it’s fully thawed, and leave it at room temp before you start
- Cavity add-ins: Toss in a lemon (quartered), an onion (quartered), plus 2 sprigs each of fresh thyme, rosemary, and sage
- Butter blend: Use ¾ cup soft butter, 6 garlic cloves (minced), and a spoonful each of chopped rosemary and thyme
- More flavor: Use black pepper and kosher salt for both the butter and the center of the turkey
- Veggies (optional): Add carrot pieces, a cut-up onion, and celery sticks to the pan if you want
How to Make It
- Start Off
- Grab your turkey from the fridge about an hour before you cook. Set that oven to 325°F. Take out the giblets, then pat the turkey as dry as you can with paper towels.
- Prep & Season
- Generously season the inside with salt and pepper. Tuck in the lemon, onion, and your fresh herbs. Mix the softened butter with chopped herbs, garlic, salt, and pepper until smooth.
- Slather on Butter
- Gently lift the skin. Spread about a third of the herby butter under the skin. Smear the rest all over the outside, getting every spot.
- Cooking Time
- Set your turkey onto the rack (or pile of veggies). Roast for fifteen minutes for every pound, until your meat thermometer says 160°F in the thickest spot. If the skin darkens too quickly, cover lightly with foil.
- Finish Up
- Rest that turkey at least 30 minutes before you slice it up. Double-check for 165°F. Carve and dig in while it’s hot.
Thawing Made Easy
Think ahead, because thawing takes longer than you might guess. Use the fridge, giving yourself a full day for every five pounds. So, a 15-pounder needs about three days. Park the wrapped turkey on a tray on the lowest fridge shelf to catch any leaks. Don’t leave it on the counter—room temp thawing can make you sick. If you’re pinched for time, put it in cold water and switch that water every half hour.
Pin it
Skip Rinsing
Leave the washing behind—it just spreads germs and makes a mess. The oven's plenty hot to kill any bugs. Just pat your turkey with paper towels instead. Dry skin means crispier skin. Don’t forget to wash your hands well after touching raw bird and use separate boards for turkey and other foods.
Stuffing Stays Out
Keep stuffing out of the turkey. Toss it in a baking dish instead. Putting it inside means your turkey takes longer and the stuffing turns soggy. Fill the middle with onions, herbs, and lemon for tasty flavor. This way, your stuffing gets a crunchy top, and your bird cooks evenly and faster.
Gold Standard Skin
Want that crispy, brown skin? Let your turkey air dry in the fridge without a cover for a couple of hours or even overnight. Rub on the herbal butter—get some under and over the skin right before roasting. Try not to peek in the oven too much or you’ll mess with the heat. No need for basting; the herbed butter takes care of business for you, making the skin perfectly crunchy and golden.
Pin it
Rest for Best Results
Let the turkey chill out for at least 30 minutes after roasting, maybe up to an hour for big ones. This keeps the juices in so you get tender slices. Cutting too early means dry turkey, so wait it out. Cover loosely with some foil so it stays warm. It’s the perfect time to whip up gravy, heat up your sides, or call everyone to the table. Waiting makes all the difference for juicy meat.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make herb butter early?
You can whip it up a couple of days beforehand. Just let it soften before spreading. Some freeze it weeks in advance, but don’t use it cold or it’ll be hard to work with. Want citrus zest? Add that fresh the same day for max flavor.
- → What if I’ve got no fresh herbs?
Dried herbs work, but use a third of the fresh amount. Mix them in so the flavors pop. Fresh is better, but dried does the trick—start small since they’re potent. Some, like thyme and rosemary, dry well, unlike basil, which isn’t as good.
- → How do I check it's ready?
Stick a thermometer in the thick part of the thigh—it should hit 158-160°F. Avoid touching the bone for an accurate read. Try a few spots just to be sure. Forget visual cues like color—temp is your best bet. White meat cooks faster, so test both. Rest it to hit 165°F for juicy perfection.
- → Should I stuff my turkey?
It’s better to cook stuffing separately—it’s safer, and the turkey cooks more evenly empty. Toss some herbs, onion, or a lemon inside for flavor. A pan-stuffed dressing gets that crunchy top as a bonus. Some skip the bread and just add citrus or herbs for aroma.
- → How long should it rest?
At least 30 minutes—45 is even better. It lets all the juices settle back into the meat. Keep it loosely covered with foil—stays warm but doesn’t get soggy. Use the rest time for gravy or finishing sides. Slice too soon, and you’ll lose all that goodness. Patience pays off!
Conclusion
Enjoy quick prep? Pair with lemon-tossed veggies or buttery garlic mashed potatoes. Even an herb chicken for comparison would wow everyone!