Pin it
This mouthwatering Italian grilled sandwich brings together buttery prosciutto, gooey cheese, and fragrant basil. It transforms simple stuff into something special - no wonder it's Stanley Tucci's favorite comfort food that feels both fancy and filling.
The first sandwich I whipped up filled my kitchen with such amazing smells from the toasty sourdough and melting mozzarella that everyone in my house showed up to see what was cooking. The trick was being patient and letting the cheese slowly melt while the bread turned perfectly golden.
Must-Have Ingredients and Shopping Guidance
- Sourdough bread: Go for a sturdy loaf with a nice crust. Bread from yesterday works great
- Fresh mozzarella: Grab those soft, milky ones stored in water. Try buffalo mozzarella for extra flavor
- Aged cheese: Pick something with bite like strong provolone or aged gruyere
- Prosciutto: Ask for paper-thin slices with good fat marbling at the deli
- Fresh basil: Look for vibrant green leaves with no wilting
- Butter: Grab unsalted and let it soften before you start
- Fresh pesto: Whip up your own or buy it from the fridge section for tastiest results
Step-by-Step Cooking Guide
- Step 1:
- Get Everything Ready: Cut bread into medium slices. Make sure butter is soft. Blot mozzarella with paper towels to remove moisture. Gather all your stuff before you begin. Warm your pan to medium heat.
- Step 2:
- Stack Your Ingredients: Spread butter on the outside of each bread slice. Start with grated cheese on the inside so it melts well. Drape prosciutto in loose waves. Scatter torn mozzarella bits across evenly. Dab pesto here and there. Top with basil leaves.
- Step 3:
- Master Your Cooking: Drop sandwich into warmed pan. Push down lightly with a spatula. Keep an eye on the heat. Listen for a soft sizzle sound. Turn over once it's golden underneath. Cover pan briefly if cheese needs help melting.
Pin it
I found out that putting a lid on the pan during the final minute of cooking really gets the cheese super melty without burning the bread. This little trick turns a good sandwich into something amazing.
Ways to Make It Your Own
What's great about this sandwich is how flexible it is: Try different bread types. Swap in other Italian cold cuts. Mix up your cheese combos. Throw in some roasted red peppers. Add a few sundried tomatoes.
Keeping It Fresh
Though it tastes best right away, you can: Get ingredients ready ahead of time. Keep your grated cheese in a separate container. Slice bread beforehand. Make extra pesto to use later.
What to Serve With It
This sandwich goes great with: A small arugula salad. A cup of plain tomato soup. A bowl of olives. Some Italian pickled veggies.
This sandwich has become my go-to quick bite for casual lunches and nice light dinners too. It shows how good ingredients and a bit of care can turn even the simplest foods into something you'll remember.
Taking It Further
The tricks that make this sandwich so good can help with other Italian-inspired dishes too. Once you get how flavors work together - salty prosciutto balancing creamy cheese, fresh herbs cutting through richness - you'll make better food of all kinds.
Drink and Food Buddies
To round out your meal: A glass of light Italian wine like Pinot Grigio. Some bubbly water with a lemon wedge. Sliced ripe figs or pears. Small-batch potato chips. A simple green salad mix.
Party Planning
This sandwich works great when you have people over: Slice into smaller pieces for snacking. Set up a make-your-own sandwich station. Cook several at once for casual get-togethers. Serve alongside platters of Italian appetizers. Pack them for outdoor eating.
Changing With The Seasons
Switch up your sandwich throughout the year: In spring - Add some tender baby greens. During summer - Slip in slices of juicy tomato. For fall - Switch basil for sage leaves. In winter - Mix in some roasted garlic spread.
Pin it
This sandwich might seem basic, but it truly captures what Italian cooking is all about - great ingredients, careful preparation, and honoring tradition while adding your own touch. It reminds us that sometimes the simplest combos make the most satisfying meals.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What’s the ideal bread to use?
- Crusty bread like sourdough is your best bet. It stays firm and crisps up perfectly.
- → Is store-bought pesto okay?
- Absolutely! Fresh is better, but a good store-bought pesto works great too.
- → Why mix two kinds of cheese?
- Mozzarella adds creaminess, and grated cheese gives it a flavorful, melty finish.
- → Can I prepare this ahead?
- It tastes best just off the pan. The crispy bread and gooey cheese are unmatched fresh.
- → What pairs well with it?
- Tomato soup or a fresh green salad makes for a classic, balanced side dish.