Pin it
This dish always brings everyone together at my table. Creamy Mushroom Chicken is something my family asks for again and again. Just a few basic things turn into a dreamy meal in half an hour. That juicy chicken tucked into a creamy mushroom blanket really is something special!
What Makes This Amazing
After lots of experimenting, this one's a breeze. No wild ingredients or tricky steps—just stuff you probably have already. That juicy chicken and that creamy mushroom sauce? I still get happy every time I whip this up. Great for weeknights, but honestly, you could totally serve it to guests and they'd be wowed!
What Goes In
- Italian Seasoning: I love throwing in a good sprinkle for extra flavor.
- Dijon Mustard: Gives that gentle punch of tang that wakes things up.
- Lemon Juice: Just a squeeze brings all the tastes alive.
- Heavy Cream: For that super-rich, smooth sauce everyone's obsessed with.
- Chicken Broth: Lays down all the savory flavor the sauce needs.
- Garlic: Fresh and minced, that’s all I use.
- Mushrooms: Both cremini or white mushrooms work great—go with whatever you’ve got.
- Olive Oil and Butter: Sautéing's so much better with both.
- Flour: Just a quick coat to help the chicken get crispy and golden.
- Chicken Breasts: Slice 'em thin so they cook fast and stay tender.
Cooking Time Together
- Bringing It All Together
- Toss everything back in your pan and let it simmer for a bit. The sauce will thicken just enough to cover every piece.
- Stir Up That Silky Sauce
- Start by cooking the garlic until it smells great, pour in your liquids, then mix in the cream nice and slow so the sauce gets creamy and smooth.
- Add Those Mushrooms
- Next up, drop the mushrooms into the pan and let them soak up all that good flavor browning up a little bit.
- Sear Your Chicken
- Once your oil and butter are hot, pop in the chicken. Cook each side till it goes golden and crispy, about 3 or 4 minutes per side.
- Get That Chicken Prepped
- Cut your chicken thin, season it well, dust it lightly with flour—trust me, it helps make that killer crust.
Make It Yours
- No Dijon? No Problem: Whole grain mustard is awesome if you want more texture.
- Need it Dairy Free?: Coconut cream is a solid swap if you skip dairy—still delicious!
- Wine Twist: A splash of white wine instead of broth gives it a little fancy boost.
- Try Switching In Thighs: Chicken thighs stay super juicy. They just need a little more time on the stove.
Best Sidekicks
Make sure you've got something to catch every last bit of that sauce! I’m all about mashed potatoes, but honestly, rice or buttered noodles are just as good. Sometimes I go for asparagus or roasted green beans too for a pop of green.
Storing Leftovers
If you’ve got extras, they’ll hang out in the fridge just fine for a few days. Warm things up gently on the stove so the sauce stays smooth. I’d skip freezing—cream sauces just get weird after thawing.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What mushrooms work the best for this?
- Use cremini for a rich flavor or white mushrooms for a milder taste. Both work perfectly.
- → Can I swap out the heavy cream?
- You can try half-and-half, but expect the sauce to be thinner. Milk isn't recommended since it may curdle.
- → Why do you cut chicken breasts in half?
- Slicing them thinner helps them cook faster and stay juicy and tender.
- → Is this something I can make ahead of time?
- Better fresh! But leftovers last 2-3 days in the fridge. Reheat slowly for best texture.
- → What sides go with it?
- Pasta, rice, or mashed potatoes are great for soaking up the sauce. Add veggies for balance!