Pin it
If you're craving something cozy, a gooey turkey melt with cheddar, bacon, spinach, and tomato on buttery sourdough totally hits the spot. Toasty bread gives a satisfying crunch, while the colorful layers of smoky turkey, sharp cheese, and fresh greens turn every bite into pure comfort.
Irresistible Grilled Sandwich
There's nothing like crafting a sandwich that just feels right. After plenty of trial and error, I've landed on this combo—cheddar oozing over smoky bacon on crispy bread, all warmed up together. It's what I whip up when I want something filling but don't have time to fuss around in the kitchen. Trust me, it never lets me down.
Stuff You'll Need
- 2 tablespoons butter, soft: Smear this on the bread for that perfect golden toast.
- 2 slices white cheddar: Pick sharp, fresh cheddar so you get the dreamiest melt.
- 4 slices deli turkey: Smoked or sweet both work, and leftover turkey is awesome for extra flavor.
- 4 crispy cooked bacon strips: Crunchy and smoky, they lift every layer.
- Thin slices from 1 ripe tomato: Juicy and bright—tomato makes it pop.
- ½ cup fresh baby spinach: Leafy greens add crunch and a healthy touch.
- 2 tablespoons honey mustard: Sweet and tangy, this sauce ties it all together.
- 4 hefty sourdough bread slices: Use bread that stands up to grilling, so it doesn't get soggy.
Ready to Cook
- Toast Away
- Heat your skillet over medium and butter the outside of each sandwich—about half a tablespoon per side. Toast until both sides are golden and cheese starts bubbling, flipping with a spatula so nothing burns. Each side usually takes three or four minutes.
- Stack Everything
- Spread honey mustard on the inside of each bread slice. Top with cheese first, then turkey and spinach, add your tomato, and finish with bacon before closing up your sandwich so all that goodness stays put.
- Dig In
- As soon as they're out of the skillet and oozy, put them on plates and enjoy while they're piping hot. Grab your favorite salad or a warm soup and make it a meal.
Getting it Just Right
If you want the best melt, don't rush it. Slow and steady means that cheese gets perfectly gooey and the bread browns up great. I always grab a block of cheddar and grate it myself—it melts way smoother than those pre-cut slices. And really, don't go light on the butter if a crispy crust is your goal.
Switch Things Up
What makes this sandwich awesome is how much you can change it. Sometimes I'll try rye or ciabatta instead of sourdough. If I'm feeling bold, I'll toss on some caramelized onions or a little pesto. When the holidays roll around, I love tucking in some cranberry sauce for a sweet-tart surprise.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What’s the benefit of block cheese?
- Slicing your own cheese from a block or getting it fresh from the deli makes it taste better and melt more smoothly compared to pre-sliced options.
- → Can you make this dairy-free?
- Totally! Just swap out the cheese and butter for dairy-free options. It’ll still be melty and delicious.
- → Why butter the bread’s outside?
- When you butter the outside, it crisps up beautifully and doesn’t stick to the pan as it toasts.
- → How can I tell when to flip it?
- You’ll know it’s time when the underside turns golden—usually after 3-4 minutes. The cheese should be melting by then, too!
- → Does layering the ingredients matter?
- Absolutely! Arranging them this way keeps everything balanced and prevents the sandwich from falling apart. Plus, it ensures the cheese fully melts.