Pin it
Biting into a well-made Reuben sandwich hits different. When you mix juicy corned beef, zesty sauerkraut, gooey Swiss cheese, and smooth thousand island dressing between crispy rye slices, you get an amazing taste combo that's been winning fans since it first showed up in NYC.
Whenever I cook these for family get-togethers, they're gone in seconds. Just the buttery rye toast smell brings everybody running to the kitchen.
Key Components and Shopping Advice
- Seeded Rye Bread: Pick fresh, firm loaves with visible seeds for sturdy sandwich structure
- Corned Beef: Ask for fresh-cut at the deli, not too thin or thick
- Sauerkraut: Grab the kind from the fridge section for better crunch and tang
- Swiss Cheese: Grate it yourself for smoother melting
- Thousand Island Dressing: Store-bought works fine, but homemade shines too
- Butter: Go with unsalted to manage the sandwich's saltiness
Step-By-Step Preparation Guide
- Step 1: Building Your Sandwich
- - Use ingredients that aren't cold from the fridge
- Stack in this pattern: bread first, then cheese, dressing, meat, and kraut
- Push down slightly without crushing everything
- Spread butter evenly on the bread exteriors - Step 2: Grilling Done Right
- - Warm pan to medium heat (skip high temps)
- Set sandwich down butter-side first
- Use light pressure with your spatula for even browning
- Wait until golden (roughly 3 minutes each side)
- Turn with care to keep fillings in place
Back in my childhood, grandma always piled extra kraut on her Reubens. She talked about its gut health perks and loved telling us how her mom fermented cabbage in wooden tubs years ago.
Heat Level Is Crucial
Getting your Reuben just right comes down to heat control. Cook too hot and you'll get blackened bread with half-melted cheese. Too cool and everything turns mushy. I've learned that keeping it at medium lets your cheese melt perfectly while your bread turns lovely and golden.
Keeping It Fresh and Planning Ahead
Reubens taste best right off the pan, but you can get stuff ready beforehand. Keep all parts separate in your fridge, but don't forget to warm up the corned beef before you build your sandwich. This tiny step really makes everything taste better.
Twists and Personal Touches
The standard Reuben works great as-is, but feel free to switch things up. Swap in pastrami for more smoky notes, or try different mustards with your thousand island. Some folks tell me they love using turkey for something lighter, though sandwich traditionalists might say that's not really a Reuben anymore.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What’s the best bread for a Reuben?
- A dark or light rye bread works great. It’s sturdy and adds extra flavor to the sandwich.
- → Is pastrami an option instead of corned beef?
- Absolutely! Pastrami works wonderfully as a substitute and adds a smoky touch.
- → How can I stop the sandwich from going soggy?
- Be sure to fully drain the sauerkraut and give your sandwich time to toast well.
- → What cheese works best here?
- Swiss cheese is ideal because it melts beautifully and has a mild flavor.
- → Can I prepare it ahead of time?
- It’s best enjoyed fresh, but you can prep the ingredients and assemble later for a quick meal.